Ports with a no_x11 variant should be changed to use x11

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

Per Macports policy against no_foo variant names, all ports with a +no_x11 variant should be changed to use +x11 instead. The dependencies and code will need to be reversed in most cases.

Some ports have no_x11 as a legacy variant, which should be retained for one year and then it can be removed.

Here's a list:

Ports with no maintainer:

• libmpeg2 (nomaintainer) (also no_sdl)
• nessus-core (nomaintainer) - the difference between gtk and x11 not clear, dependencies are broken (#38114, #42156)

Ports with open maintainer:

• gstreamer010-gst-plugins-base (rmstonecipher, open) (see gstreamer1-gst-plugins-base; also no_gnome_vfs, no_ogg)
• surf (gmail.com:shreevatsa.public, open)

Other ports:

• gnokii (ieee.org:mpal1+bugzilla)
• gtk2hs (gwright)
• wireshark (darkart.com:opendarwin.org) (compare with wireshark-devel, also has no_adns, no_geoip, no_gnutls, no_ipv6, no_libgcrypt, no_libsmi, no_lua, no_rtp, no_ssl, no_x11)

Ports with both x11 and no_x11 by date:

• graphviz & graphviz-devel (ryandesign) - x11 since r102579 2013-02-04
• ImageMagick (ryandesign) - x11 since r106049 2013-05-13
• libunique (devans, open) - x11 since r107051 2013-06-16
• gnome-sharp2 (nomaintainer) - x11 since r107104 2013-06-18
• libgnomekbd (devans, open) - x11 since r107083 2013-06-17
• libbonoboui (nomaintainer) - x11 since r107293 2013-06-25
• libgnomeui (nomaintainer) - x11 since r107294 2013-06-25
• gromacs & gromacs-double (nomaintainer) - x11 since r108345 2013-07-20
• gwyddion (rowue, gwyddion.net:yeti) - +quartz since r108367 2013-07-21
• openssh (nomaintainer) - +xauth since r108465 2013-07-23
• gd2 (ryandesign) - x11 since r109413 2013-08-14
• pgplot (mcalhoun, open) - x11 since r110730 2013-09-04
• mpeg2vidcodec (nomaintainer). x11 added in r110736 2013-09-04
• gstreamer1-gst-plugins-base (rmstonecipher, open) x11 and ogg added in r113914 2013-11-25
• efte (reiffert, open) - x11 since r115028 2013-12-22
• basiliskii-devel (nomaintainer) - gtk since r115460 / r115462 2014-01-02
• sheepshaver (nomaintainer) - +gtk since r115661 2014-01-08 (see #30672, port broken)
• pidgin (devans, open) - x11 since r119699 2014-05-03

Ports with x11 only/fixed

• at-spi (nomaintainer) - no_x11 removed in r106775.
• cairo-devel (ryandesign) - x11 since r78848 2011-05-24, no_x11 removed in r111805.
• darktable (gmail.com:julians37) - x11 since r75631 2011-02-01; no_x11 has never been a compatibility variant. no_x11 removed in r118500, r118501.
• gedit (devans, open) - no_x11 removed in r106998.
• giflib (ryandesign) - x11 since r93239 2012-05-17, no_x11 removed in r115523.
• gnuplot (mojca, open) - x11 since r96459 2012-08-10, no_x11 removed in r108795.
• ghostscript (takanori, open) - no_x11 removed in r112515.
• ghostscript-fonts-hiragino (takanori, open) - no_alias removed in r112516.
• gstreamer010-gst-plugins-bad (rmstonecipher, open) - no_x11 removed in r119678.
• gstreamer1-gst-plugins-bad (rmstonecipher, open) - no_x11 removed in r113908.
• gtk2 (nomaintainer) - x11 changes since r103155 2013-02-16, variant existed earlier. no_x11 removed in r118503.
• gtk3 (cal, open) - x11 changes since r103160 2013-02-16, variant existed earlier. no_x11 removed in r118504.
• kmymoney4 (mk, pixilla, open) removed in r110987
• kmymoney4-devel (mk, pixilla, open) removed in r110986
• libsdl (jmr, open) - x11 since r78823 2011-05-23. no_x11 removed in r109316.
• mjpegtools (gmail.com:filippo.natali) - x11 since r87467 2011-11-22. no_x11 removed in r118502.
• mlt (dennedy.org:dan) - Probably should be called +gtk2 instead and reversed. no_x11 removed in r110684.
• openvrml (raphael, open) - x11 since r82212 and r82194 2011-08-10. no_x11 and no_opengl removed in r110726.
• plplot & plplot-single (takeshi, open) - x11 since r99946 2012-11-21, no_x11 removed in r108600.
• pTeX (takanori, open) (also has no_hiragino, no_otf, no_x11) removed in r111190.
• texlive-bin (dports) - x11 since r82097 2011-08-07, no_x11 removed in r108863.
• transcode (cogweb.net:lionteeth, devans)

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

at-spi: r106775

[cooljeanius (Eric Gallager)]

Cc Me!

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

Replying to macsforever2000@…:

Some ports have no_x11 as a legacy variant, but I don't see a reason to keep them around since they do nothing.

The no_x11 legacy variants exist so that users who had previously selected those variants will continue to have X11 disabled after upgrading. All ports that are converted from no_x11 to x11 variants should maintain such a no_x11 legacy variant for one year so that users upgrading the ports do not suddenly receive features they specifically requested not to receive.

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

While I'm ready to patch at any time - what about the rule that "updates are supposed to run smoothly for a year after the change"?

Gnuplot introduced the option +x11 in August 2012 (r96459). If there is anyone who installed gnuplot with +no_x11 back in July 2012, the update won't go as expected.

While this is hardly a problem for gnuplot (it's been 10 months now which is almost a year): aren't there going to be problems in other packages if an option is simply removed without any grace period?

PS: I'm sorry. I only noticed now that Ryan actually said the same thing. I didn't see his post earlier.

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

Here's a grouped list created out of the list above. I didn't check if any other ports contain [no_]x11, I didn't check ports for which it says "remove legacy no_x11", but I checked if any port added +x11 recently.

If anyone wants or agrees with the list, it can be moved to the top description and updates as work proceeds, I didn't dare to do that.

Ports without x11 variant:

Ports with no maintainer:

• libmpeg2 (nomaintainer) (also no_sdl)
• mpeg2vidcodec (nomaintainer)
• nessus-core (nomaintainer) - the difference between gtk and x11 not clear, dependencies are broken (#38114)

Ports with open maintainer:

• efte (reiffert, open)
• ghostscript (takanori, open)
• gstreamer1-gst-plugins-bad (rmstonecipher, open)
• gstreamer1-gst-plugins-base (rmstonecipher, open) (also no_gnome_vfs, no_ogg)
• gstreamer010-gst-plugins-bad (rmstonecipher, open)
• gstreamer010-gst-plugins-base (rmstonecipher, open) (also no_gnome_vfs, no_ogg)
• kmymoney4 (mk, pixilla, open) (also no_gtk)
• kmymoney4-devel (mk, pixilla, open) (also no_gtk)
• pgplot (mcalhoun, open) (#39818)
• pTeX (takanori, open) (also has no_hiragino, no_otf, no_x11)
• surf (gmail.com:shreevatsa.public, open)

Other ports:

• basiliskii-devel (vercruesse.de:opendarwin.nospam)
• gajim-devel (rene)
• gnokii (ieee.org:mpal1+bugzilla)
• gtk2hs (gwright)
• mlt (dennedy.org:dan) - Probably should be called +gtk2 instead and reversed
• pidgin (otherware.org:nefar)
• sheepshaver (vercruesse.de:opendarwin.nospam)
• wireshark (darkart.com:opendarwin.org) (compare with wireshark-devel, also has no_adns, no_geoip, no_gnutls, no_ipv6, no_libgcrypt, no_libsmi, no_lua, no_rtp, no_ssl, no_x11)

Ports with both x11 and no_x11 by date:

• graphviz & graphviz-devel (ryandesign) - x11 since r102579 2013-02-04
• gtk2 (nomaintainer) - x11 changes since r103155 2013-02-16, variant existed earlier
• gtk3 (cal, open) - x11 changes since r103160 2013-02-16, variant existed earlier
• ImageMagick (ryandesign) - x11 since r106049 2013-05-13
• libunique (devans, open) - x11 since r107051 2013-06-16
• gnome-sharp2 (nomaintainer) - x11 since r107104 2013-06-18
• libgnomekbd (devans, open) - x11 since r107083 2013-06-17
• libbonoboui (nomaintainer) - x11 since r107293 2013-06-25
• libgnomeui (nomaintainer) - x11 since r107294 2013-06-25
• gromacs & gromacs-double (nomaintainer) - x11 since r108345 2013-07-20
• gwyddion (rowue, gwyddion.net:yeti) - +quartz since r108367 2013-07-21
• openssh (nomaintainer) - +xauth since r108465 2013-07-23
• gd2 (ryandesign) - (version 2.1 will have x11)

Ports where no_x11 may be removed:

• cairo-devel (ryandesign) - x11 since r78848 2011-05-24
• darktable (gmail.com:julians37) - x11 since r75631 2011-02-01; no_x11 has never been a compatibility variant
• giflib (ryandesign) - x11 since r93239 2012-05-17
• libsdl (jmr, open) - x11 since r78823 2011-05-23
• mjpegtools (gmail.com:filippo.natali) - x11 since r87467 2011-11-22
• openvrml (raphael, open) - x11 since r82212 and r82194 2011-08-10

Ports with x11 only/fixed

• at-spi (nomaintainer) - no_x11 removed in r106775.
• gedit (devans, open) - no_x11 removed in r106998. - gnuplot (mojca, open) - x11 since r96459 2012-08-10, no_x11 removed in r108795.
• plplot & plplot-single (takeshi, open) - x11 since r99946 2012-11-21, no_x11 removed in r108600.
• texlive-bin (dports) - x11 since r82097 2011-08-07, no_x11 removed in r108863.
• transcode (cogweb.net:lionteeth, devans)

[neverpanic (Clemens Lang)]

openssh in r108465.

[mirimiri66@…]

Cc Me!

[mirimiri66@…]

Regarding openssh; Now that no_x11 has been removed, how can xorg components be prevented from installing?

port -y upgrade openssh -xauth doesn't seem to work.

[neverpanic (Clemens Lang)]

Replying to mirimiri66@…:

port -y upgrade openssh -xauth doesn't seem to work.

Try port upgrade --enforce-variants openssh -xauth. I should probably have added --without-xauth to make sure, though.

[tenomoto (Takeshi Enomoto)]

plplot in r108600.

[mirimiri66@…]

Replying to cal@…:

Replying to mirimiri66@…:

port -y upgrade openssh -xauth doesn't seem to work.

Try port upgrade --enforce-variants openssh -xauth. I should probably have added --without-xauth to make sure, though.

It still pulls in xorg components.

[neverpanic (Clemens Lang)]

Replying to mirimiri66@…:

It still pulls in xorg components.

Please file a separate bug for this an cc me, if it still persists. Attach the main.log and explain how it "pulls in xorg components". I cannot reproduce and the dependency list of openssh -xauth (port rdeps openssh -xauth) seems to correctly reflect the variant.

[drkp (Dan Ports)]

Removed the compatibility variant from texlive-bin in r108863.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

Removed from libsdl in r109316 by jmr.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

Per email, basiliskii-devel and sheepshaver are no longer being maintained by vercruesse.de:opendarwin.nospam.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

cal removed no_x11 from mlt in r110684.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

no_x11 and no_opengl removed from openvrml in r110726.

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

Recently added x11:

• gd2 (ryandesign) - x11 since r109413 2013-08-14
• pgplot (mcalhoun, open) - x11 since r110730 2013-09-04

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

added x11 to mpeg2vidcodec in r110736.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

pTeX fixed in r111190.

[takanori@…]

ghostscript fixed in r112515

[takanori@…]

ghostscript-fonts-hiragino fixed in r112516

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

• gajim-devel port doesn't exist any longer
• cairo-devel, gstreamer1-gst-plugins-bad no longer contain no_x11, removed from list of ports
• gstreamer1-gst-plugins-base now has x11
• ghostscript, kmymoney4, kmymoney4-devel, libsdl, mlt, openvrml, pTeX removed from list of ports (they no longer contain no_x11)

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

added gtk to basiliskii-devel in r115460 / r115462.

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

I attached a Portfile for sheepshaver to #30672. The problem is that the compilation is broken. What do you think about committing the patch nevertheless?

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

• giflib: no_x11 removed in r115523.
• sheepshaver: +gtk since r115661 (but see #30672: port is broken)

We can start the final countdown": only nine more ports to go ;)

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

• darktable: no_x11 removed in r118500, r118501
• mjpegtools: no_x11 removed in r118502
• gtk2: no_x11 removed in r118503
• gtk3: no_x11 removed in r118504

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

• libmpeg2 (nomaintainer) – +x11 since r118506 2014-04-03

[mirimiri66@…]

Cc Me!

[dbevans (David B. Evans)]

gstreamer010-gst-plugins-bad: no_x11 removed in r119678.

[dbevans (David B. Evans)]

pidgin: +x11 added in r119699.