_resources/port1.0/livecheck/googlecode.tcl: livecheck broken

[l2dy (Zero King)]

Google Code is using angular now and livecheck could only find a <div ng-view></div>.

Example URL: ​http://code.google.com/p/arowpp/downloads/list --302--> ​https://code.google.com/archive/p/arowpp/downloads

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

I would prefer to keep the livecheck broken for now and rather have a ticket with all ports that still use google code and start an effort to move those ports away from google code.

The particular example of arowapp: the "​homepage" says:

The project has moved to ​https://github.com/tetsuok/arowpp.

so we should use a GitHub PortGroup and fix the port anyway.

We should not be using google code for anything but obsolete software that is no longer maintained. Disabling the livecheck as a quick fix will just hide the problem. Sure, we may disable it eventually, but we certainly need a ticket tracking progress of moving ports away from google code.

[l2dy (Zero King)]

The problem is I'm going to run port livecheck all from time to time and checking these ports would be a waste of time.

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

Another option (I'm not sure how to implement that though) would be to throw some more informative warning. Instead of getting the useless

Error: cannot check if FOO was updated (regex didn't match)

it would help if port livecheck -v would return something like

Warning: FOO is hosted on google code which is no longer being updated

(but of course with a better message).

Again, as a quick fix we could also disable livecheck if needed, but let's make a ticket with all google code projects first.

[l2dy (Zero King)]

ag -G Portfile -l 'master_sites[ \t]+googlecode' | awk -F/ '{print $2}' | tr '\n' ' '; echo

namebench qlipper xar lastfmlib libofa rgm3800py s710 asmotor atf closure-linter cmockery darts-clone distcc fortrancl google-ctemplate ocaml-bitstring ocaml-extlib qdjango qxmpp re2 rlog sbt-0.7 yaml-cpp sigil log4erl bindfs s3fs libkml flam3 gpick libguichan sam2p squish tif22pnm dircproxy appengine-java-sdk dex2jar dualist fantom google-collections hamcrest-core hamcrest-library lucene-gosen2 lucene-gosen4 microemu objenesis scala-migrations spymemcached arowpp bayon crfpp crfpp-devel oll plda mp4v2 tovid csshX dsocks exabgp flowd gsutil naim pdsh php-peb ttf2eot py-amqplib py-apsw py-argparse py-bitstring py-chm2pdf py-djvubind py-gchartwrapper py-gdata py-gflags py-graphy py-gslib py-gtfs py-gviz_api py-harstorage py-hcluster py-iniparse py-ipaddr py-lepton py-libdnet py-libnamebench py-lockfile py-mingus py-mox py-nmrglue py-pdfrw py-pebl py-progressbar py-psychopy py-pybonjour py-pybox2d py-pydot py-pygraph-core py-pygraph-dot py-pymunk py-pyodbc py-pypcap py-pysam py-rfoo py-sqlite py-tesser py-twitter py-winpdb py-workerpool py-xar py27-webkitgtk log2timeline openfpc reaver skipfish crswallow exec-wrapper macports-notifier memcachedb memcacheq nrg4iso pssh synergy-devel zsh-templates-osx dot2texi agree backward cabocha cpi00 daisydiff epubcheck giza-pp iksemel liblouis liblouisxml marisa-trie pdf2json rst2pdf stardict txt2tags ux-trie arora blazeblogger googlecl mod_authn_otp mongoose sitemap_gen xdotool

ag -G Portfile -l 'master_sites.+googlecode.com' | awk -F/ '{print $2}' | tr '\n' ' '; echo

qtscriptgenerator grok

ag -G Portfile -l 'svn.url.+googlecode.com' | awk -F/ '{print $2}' | tr '\n' ' '; echo

CronniX xar-devel rgm3800 gtest hs-hoc hs-HOC-AppKit hs-HOC-Cocoa hs-HOC-CoreData hs-HOC-Foundation hs-HOC-QuartzCore osgswig-devel jsr305 v8 sofia-ml py-swap word2vec

[l2dy (Zero King)]

I've created #53467, can we disable livecheck for these ports now?

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

You are certain that all of the ports currently hosted at googlecode are at their latest googlecode version? I'm not. If not, then we should fix googlecode livecheck so that it works properly.

[l2dy (Zero King)]

I just don't think it would worth the effort. After all these ports are upgraded to latest version on Google Code or moved, googlecode livecheck should be disabled anyway.

If you're interested in fixing it, here's a new URL: ​https://www.googleapis.com/storage/v1/b/google-code-archive/o/v2%2Fcode.google.com%2Farowpp%2Fdownloads-page-1.json?alt=media&stripTrailingSlashes=false

Edit: Unless moved to ... is also detected programmatically, we have to go through every port manually anyway. That's why I said it wouldn't worth the effort. Still some ports might have moved without a notice or redirect on Google Code.

[l2dy (Zero King)]

port's livecheck for Google Code projects could only checks updates on Google Code and can be broken if livecheck.regex was overridden.

Were we to go through the ports with a script, the script needs to detect moved projects and updates within Google Code for projects that didn't move. We should also search on GitHub and Google for possible active forks or new locations not mentioned on Google Code.